Project planning

Finding and Sorting the Keyed Doors Before an Access Control Change

← All articles

To plan an access control change without missing keyed doors, walk the whole building before the project is scoped and list every door that opens with a mechanical key, not just the main entrances. Then decide on purpose what each keyed door will do under the new plan: stay keyed, get upgraded, or wait on a policy decision. An access change is only as consistent as its least-controlled opening.

Why a keyed door can undo the new access rules

An access control system decides who can open the doors it manages and keeps a record of each entry. A mechanical key does neither. If a stairwell or loading door still opens with a key, anyone holding that key has a way in that the new system cannot log or shut off.

The gap shows when someone leaves. Their credential is turned off at the front door, but the key in their pocket still opens the back one. Keyed doors belong in the plan even if none of them are being replaced.

What to record at each keyed door

Walk every level with a floor plan or a rough sketch, trying each door instead of working from memory. At each door that uses a key, write down where it is, in words someone new to the building could follow, and what it protects: storage, mechanical equipment, network gear, a tenant space, or the roof.

Note who uses the door and how often. Record how it is keyed, including whether it is on a master key, meaning one key that opens many locks. Then mark whether the door sits on an accessible route or exit path, or gets used after hours.

Once the walk is done, compare the key records to what you found. A log full of former staff, or no log at all, means those doors are not really controlled. A door where nobody can say who holds keys is a finding in itself. Write it down that way instead of guessing.

How to sort each door: stay keyed, upgrade, or decide

Sort the list in a fixed order so the easy calls do not crowd out the hard ones.

  1. Rate what the door protects. A cleaning closet and a network room carry different risk.
  2. Note how often it is used and by whom. A busy door shared by rotating staff is a poor match for a key that gets passed around.
  3. Count the key holders. A short, known list on a low-risk door points toward leaving it keyed.
  4. Look at whether the door lets people skip a controlled entrance. If it does, it usually needs an upgrade or a strict key rule.
  5. Move anything that hinges on policy, such as tenant or vendor access, into a needs-a-decision group and name who decides.

Keeping a door keyed is a valid result when the choice is deliberate and written down, with rules for who holds keys, where spares are kept, and what happens when one goes missing.

Door condition can change the answer. If the door drags or the latch does not catch when it closes, no lock will keep it shut, so note that before anyone chooses hardware. A keyed door on an accessible route, or one fitted with an automatic door operator, should be flagged so accessibility gets reviewed alongside the lock.

Doors a main-entrance plan tends to skip

Service entrances are the most common gap. Loading doors, delivery side doors, and trash-room exits get treated as operations doors, yet each one is a way into the building.

Stairwell and roof doors are easy to skip because people pass through them without thinking of them as entry points. They often raise life-safety questions a key list cannot settle, so mark them for review by whoever is responsible for that side of the building.

Shared doors are risky because the keys sit outside your staff. A corridor door shared with a tenant, or a room a vendor maintains, may have key holders your records never included.

Mechanical, electrical, and IT rooms often house equipment the new access system depends on, so a loose key to them matters more than it looks. Also look for cages, gates, and interior doors added during past renovations. They rarely show up on older drawings.

What to give the contractor before scoping

The scoping conversation goes better when it starts from the whole building instead of the front door. Bring:

  • The keyed-door list, with what each door protects
  • Current key-holder information, including the gaps
  • Decisions already made, and the reason for each
  • Open questions, with the person who will answer each one
  • Doors on accessible routes or with after-hours use

Atlas Integrated Security works on access control, commercial door hardware, and commercial smart locks for commercial buildings in New York City. To go through your list before the project is scoped, call (347) 357-0985.

Frequently asked questions

Can a building run access control on some doors and keys on others?

Yes, a building can run access control on its main entrances and keep mechanical keys on low-traffic rooms. The mix holds up when each keyed door is chosen on purpose, its key holders are known, and the keys follow written rules. It breaks down when a keyed door offers an easy way around a controlled entrance.

Who should be involved in deciding which keyed doors change?

Deciding which keyed doors change should include the facility team or building management, whoever handles life safety, IT if network rooms are on the list, and a tenant or vendor contact for shared doors. Give each needs-a-decision door one named owner who makes the final call, or the list tends to stall.

What if nobody knows who holds keys to certain doors?

A door with unknown key holders cannot be treated as controlled, whatever lock is on it, so move it up the priority list. The usual paths are rekeying, which changes the lock so existing keys stop working, replacing the lock, or bringing the door under access control.

Should keyed doors be reviewed again after the new system goes live?

Yes. After the access control system goes live, check the keyed doors against the list again. Habits shift once card readers are in, and people may start using a keyed door to avoid one. New tenants, staff changes, and renovations also add keys and doors, so repeat the check after each of those.

Next step